Insurance Products

At Youngstown Insurance Agency (YIA), we offer a full range of personal insurance solutions designed to protect the things that matter most.

Whether you're looking for reliable auto insurance in Youngstown, affordable homeowners insurance, or the right coverage for your motorcycle, jewelry, or identity protection, our licensed team is here to help.

A GEICO Exclusive Agency

We proudly serve Boardman, Canfield, Poland, Austintown, and the greater Youngstown–Warren area and combine personalized service with powerful national coverage options to deliver real peace of mind.

Auto & Car Insurance

Car insurance isn’t just a requirement – it’s a key part of protecting your financial future. Our team offers fast, accurate quotes and we'll walk you through liability limits, collision and comprehensive coverage, deductible options, and discounts you may qualify for – including safe driver, multi-vehicle, and bundling discounts.

Whether you drive a new car, a used truck, or a daily commuter, we’ll make sure your car insurance is right for your budget and your driving habits. We help with new policies, policy transfers, and same-day coverage, all from our local office in Boardman.

Home & Homeowners Insurance

Your home is one of your most important assets – and it deserves the right protection. At YIA, we provide homeowners insurance policies designed to cover not just your structure and belongings, but also your personal liability and temporary living expenses in case of a covered loss.

We quote policies from multiple trusted carriers, so we can compare rates and coverages to find the best solution for your property and your budget. Whether you own a single-family home in Canfield or a townhome in Austintown, we’ll explain your options clearly and recommend the right coverage levels for your needs.

Renters & Condo Insurance

If you’re renting or living in a condo, you still need coverage for what’s inside your walls – your furniture, electronics, clothing, and more. Our renters insurance and condo insurance policies are designed to protect your personal property and provide liability coverage in case of accidents or damage.

These policies are typically very affordable and can be bundled with your car insurance to unlock additional savings. We'll make sure you understand what is and isn’t covered so you feel confident in your protection.

Motorcycle & ATV Insurance

As of May 2025, our office is excited to offer a new motorcycle insurance product with more personalized coverage options and better rates than ever before. Whether you ride a Harley, a sport bike, or an ATV, our motorcycle insurance options include protection for your bike, your gear, your passengers, and yourself.

We’ll walk you through essential coverages like bodily injury, property damage, comprehensive, and uninsured motorist – plus optional add-ons for roadside assistance, accessory coverage, and more. We help you ride with confidence, whether you’re hitting the open road or exploring Ohio’s backcountry trails.

Boat Insurance

Spend time on the water without worrying about what could go wrong. Our boat insurance policies provide coverage for a variety of vessels, from fishing boats and pontoons to jet skis and sailboats. Coverage can include physical damage, liability, fuel spill cleanup, theft, and even towing.

Whether you use your boat on Lake Milton or travel across state lines for weekend getaways, we’ll make sure you have the right protection before you launch.

Jewelry Insurance

Standard homeowners and renters policies often have limited coverage for high-value items like engagement rings, watches, or family heirlooms. We offer separate jewelry insurance policies that provide extended protection, even if your item is lost, stolen, or damaged outside the home.

With an affordable premium and broad coverage, jewelry insurance gives you peace of mind that your most treasured pieces are safe.

Identity Theft Protection

Identity theft is one of the fastest-growing crimes in the U.S. Our identity protection coverage offers ongoing credit monitoring, fraud alerts, recovery assistance, and financial reimbursement if you become a victim. We help you stay one step ahead of cybercriminals and protect your credit, reputation, and hard-earned assets.

Bundle and Save

One of the easiest ways to save on your premiums is to bundle multiple policies. Whether you're combining auto and home insurance, adding renters or motorcycle coverage, or insuring multiple vehicles, we’ll help you take advantage of GEICO’s multi-policy discounts.

Experience the YIA Difference

Our team is ready to help you compare quotes, understand your options, and choose the right protection for your home, vehicles, and valuables. Whether you're shopping for auto insurance in Youngstown, looking for a better motorcycle insurance policy, or need expert advice on homeowners insurance, we’ve got your back.

Contact Us

Our Google Reviews

4.9 rating out of 336 reviews
View More Reviews
I recently moved to Ohio and needed both renters and car insurance. Chase and the GEICO team made the process so smooth and stress-free! Chase’s customer service was friendly, knowledgeable, and walked me through every step. I was able to bundle both policies at a great rate, and everything...
Destiny Armstrong Youngstown, OH
Meg was amazing she helped me save money by bundling my home, auto, and camper policy. I love having a one stop shop where I can take care of all my needs. Excellent service!
Jose Hernandez Youngstown, OH
Meg was very professional and easy to deal with. She was a great communicator and was easy to understand. I came in with concerns about my auto policy. She gave me a solution to my problem and I left happy!
John D Youngstown, OH
I recently moved to Ohio and needed both renters and car insurance. Chase and the GEICO team made the process so smooth and stress-free! Chase’s customer service was friendly, knowledgeable, and walked me through every step. I was able to bundle both policies at a great rate, and everything...
Destiny Armstrong Youngstown, OH
Meg was amazing she helped me save money by bundling my home, auto, and camper policy. I love having a one stop shop where I can take care of all my needs. Excellent service!
Jose Hernandez Youngstown, OH
Meg was very professional and easy to deal with. She was a great communicator and was easy to understand. I came in with concerns about my auto policy. She gave me a solution to my problem and I left happy!
John D Youngstown, OH
Previous Review
Next Review